Imminent FulfillmentImmortality,  Safety, Empowerment, Equality, KnowledgeUnity, Society

Should not intelligent, reasonable men of good will be able to agree on all things that matter?

"There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to
  one who is striking at the root."
- Henry David Thoreau
Site Sections, Subject List, Article Synopses and other features

Introduction Material
Introduction Articles
Word Definitions
Human Condition

Christianity Material
Bible/Canon Issues
Christendom Analyzed

Jesus Material
Jesus' Teachings
Aspects of Jesus
5 Gospels Canon

Philosophy Material
Academic Education
Paradigm Material
Philosophers of Note
Philosophical Issues
Philosophy Metaphysics
Psychological Issues
Religious Miscellaneous
Sociological Material
Theological Basics
Theological Issues
Theological Misc

Theological Skeptical

Cosmology, Creation,
Geophysical Material

Cosmology Material
Creation Issues
Geophysical Material

Reconstruction &
Mythology Material
Chronology Revision
Golden Age Themes
History Revision
Misc Ancient Myth Material
Modern Mythology Material
Psycho-Catastrophe Articles
Saturn-Jupiter Material
Symbol Development
Venus-Mars Material
1994 Velikovsky Symposium

Miscellaneous Material
Book Critiques Links
Misc Biology Links
Misc Issues/Conclusions
Poetry & Fun Material
PDF Download Files
Lecture & Video Links
Site Features Links
Spiritual Products online store


Yeshua didn't even begin his public ministry until he was spiritually mature, and his suffering and death represented not something called for or inevitable, but rather the FAILURE of mankind at the time to open the mind and understand his message and his Gospel. - Site Author

The 12 Disciples
Updated: 05/11/2020

Why should we be critical of the 12 disciples?

First of all, let's remember that the disciples were Israelites, and saturated with the Judaic religion and tradition. This is a "what is", and doesn't make them worse off in general than the rest of the Israelite population.

Second, let's understand that Yeshua did not specifically "select" them as being special, and certainly not with any kind of special "foreknowledge" of what they would do or become.. His invitation was open for anybody to follow him, and most of the time his followers gravitated to HIM. Given that Yeshua may have invited many other men to follow him, it may only SEEM that Yeshua made any special effort to contact Peter, Andrew, James, John, Phillip, Nathaniel (Bartholomew), and Matthew, and those accounts need to be seen in the same context of his approaching ZacchAeus in the tree. Yeshua invited others, including the rich young ruler, to follow him in the same general way, and many did.

A second recurring motif [of Mark] is the strange obtuseness of Yeshua's followers, who are represented as incapable of understanding almost anything their Master says or does. When Yeshua stills a storm the disciples are impressed but unaware of the act's significance (Mark 4:35-41). After his feeding of the multitudes, the disciples "had not understood the intent of the loaves" (Mark 6: 52). After listening for months to Yeshua's teaching, they are still ignorant of what this 'rising from the dead' could mean (Mark 9:9-10). They not only fail to comprehend the meaning of sharing in Yeshua's glory, (Mark 10:35-41, even the simplest, most obvious parables escape their understanding Mark 4:10-13). As Yeshua asks, "You do not understand this parable? How will you understand any parable?" (Mark 4:13) - Harris, Stephen L, Understanding the Bible, Mayfield Publishing Company, Palo Alto, CA, 1987, p.287.

For whatever reason, mostly superficial or because of the ancient Israelite paradigm of twelve tribes, a dozen of his followers became featured in the Gospel accounts, and became "institutionalized" as a special, formal group of disciples. Some of the others may not have been as free to roam around the country as these twelve were, but we can hardly imagine that these twelve were more astute, enlightened or special than were Mary, Martha and Lazarus, and especially Joseph and Nicodemus.

Also let's acknowledge that for the most part these twelve men were ignorant lower class fishermen. We can visualize that they were accustomed to fishing naked at night for a few fish to sell in the morning, and were NOT used to thinking about nor discussing philosophical or theological issues. And when he was trying to warn them and prepare them for his crucifixion and ordeal. Yeshua even had to advise them to refrain from strong drink!

Consider Peter! He sets the standard for the gregarious, intellectually irresponsible, emotional man who wasn't into contemplation of his own fallibility nor much of anything else. It is hard to see that he learned anything from his time with Yeshua except a little humility.

Sealed in the truth?

There is a concept extant in Christendom that the disciples were "sealed in the truth. For the most part, they were "sealed" all right, but not in the truth. To be sealed in the truth means that you have entered the Kingship of the Heavens, and most of the twelve disciples never did this.

Falsity of private confessions and absolutions

One of the worst, most confused mistranslations done by New Testament translators of Christendom is the one in John 20:23. Contrary to what most "authorized" translations have him saying here, Yeshua is not giving his disciples authority to seal judgment on the "sins" (fundamentally wrong concepts of God) of others. This was not a license to become "Fathers" and hear confessions from underlings and give absolution! Rather, any sins that the disciples were able to "dismiss" in others, in the same way as Yeshua did, would come through their exposition of the truth that set men free, NOT from hearing private confessions..

Yeshua is at the end of his ministry, his all out effort to cleanse our thinking of dreadfully wrong concepts of God, and now he can do no more. This is his benediction, his coming to terms with the fact that the disciples and followers had retained a great deal of misunderstanding in their thinking. He is addressing this regrettable result, and Mankind has paid a heavy price for their carelessness, dullness, intellectual irresponsibility and spiritual apathy.

Even though Yeshua has "explained everything" (Mark 4:33-34; see also Mark 8:31-32) and the disciples have presumably recognized him as the Messiah (Mark 8:27-32), they desert him after his arrest (Mark 14:50). Peter, who had earlier confessed Yeshua to be the Messiah, three times denies knowing him (Mark 14:66-72). Almost the only character in Mark who perceives the meaning of Yeshua's death is an unnamed Roman centurion who affirms that "truly this man was the son of God!" (Mark 15:39). - Harris, Stephen L, Understanding the Bible, Mayfield Publishing Company, Palo Alto, CA, 1987, p.289-90..

These are the men that Christendom has made into idols, and worship as having been "sealed" into the truth? Pathetic! Absurd!

Apparently only two of these wrote anything that indicated they understood the message of Yeshua, and that only after the resurrection. John was probably more amenable because he was so young and therefore with a fresher mind less hardened in Judaism, and Thomas, probably because he was more of a critical thinker and less spiritually gullible., who at least THOUGHT about the issues. Why else was Thomas the only one with whom Yeshua had private conversation and confided the MOST radical thinking? See: Thomas 13,14.

Suffice it to say, that during his time with them they were not really getting their minds on the track laid out for them. They were not asking Yeshua good, relevant, insightful questions, not listening to his entire message, and especially not believing it. The lack of questions that were asking is appalling, and implies minds that were not awake and active. They were no doubt fascinated with Yeshua, felt loved, and felt that they were a part of something special. but this is far from meaning that they were being intellectually responsible or that they understood the Gospel or conceived the Kingship of the heavens.

For the most part, these followers proved to be impervious to the truth and understanding that Yeshua was trying to foster, and yet they took it upon themselves to be God's special representatives, otherwise known as apostles. Specifically, Yeshua told them a half dozen times that he was going to be killed and resurrected, and yet when it happened they were shocked and devastated by his death and incredulous about his resurrection. The end result was that only a few–maybe only two–came to their senses after the resurrection, but the rest not only did not, but died or were killed. How ironic and tragic that these latter including their misunderstandings became the basis for the world's largest and most powerful yet false religion.

Let's be mindful of this account:

Thomas 43. His disciples said to him, "Who are you, that you should say these things to us?" Yeshua said to them, "You do not realize who I am from what I say to you, but you have become like the Jews, for they either love the tree and hate its fruit or love the fruit and hate the tree."

Commentary: Being spiritually blind and mind-heart hardened, most of Yeshua's disciples misunderstood his message and mission, and  missed the significance and the great redemption that Yeshua came to inaugurate. They became spiritually schizophrenic and unable to enter the kingship of the heavens. They were incapable of realizing that this was the Original human being, the original Creator of the Universe come to give them and all the universe an age-ending demonstration for all time.

Much ado has been made over their squabbles and petty competition for a high place in their expected future hierarchy, but these minor foibles pale in comparison to their more serious intellectual and spiritual deficiencies. Instead of being ignored, excused or glossed over, the disciples' failures should be legendary and featured. We can hardly do worse unless we simply repeat their mistakes.. Among other things, they failed:

  • to recognize what and who Yeshua really was
  • to pay more than minimal attention to what he was saying
  • to realize that his message was NOT compatible with their current beliefs
  • to ask relevant questions and expect or demand to understand
  • to overcome their racism and illusion of superiority over the gentiles
  • to understand that Yeshua was the incarnation and public, tangible demonstration of the Creator, his nature, his character, and his values
  • to see that his nature is to serve, not to dominate
  • to come into the unity for which he so passionately and eloquently asked
  • to overcome their hierarchal paradigm of organizational and social order
  • to capitalize on the tremendous privilege that they were granted
  • to stay together and form a genuine ecclesia and a core of believers that would grow exponentially
  • to bring a resolution and end to the human condition

Among other unfortunate developments. these failures have led to:

  • a formal and rigid leadership structure
  • the institutionalization of Christendom
  • the Christian alliance with the secular powers
  • the Christian amalgamation with the Greek mystery religions
  • the retention of the triune polytheism (the Trinity)
  • the Christian retention of the Zoroastrian dualism (Lord-of-Darkness Devil versus Lord-of-Light Yeshua)
  • the Christian reification of spirit into a ghostly entity or member of the Godhead
  • the Christian reification of evil and the original lie into a literal devil with legions of literal, depraved demons
  • the Christian reification of the Kingship of the Heavens into a literal, tangible territory in the universe called "Heaven"
  • the adoption of a literal Hell with unspeakable eternal punishment by burning unforgiven sinners alive
  • the Christian retention of the Saturnian God paradigm
  • the Christian retention of legalism, and a pretentious system to overcome it
  • a proliferation of ancient but now empty rites, sacraments, ceremonies, liturgies, icons and symbols
  • the sacralization of architecture and buildings
  • the Christian fragmentation into different major divisions, denominations, orders and sects
  • a morass of confusion and doctrinal disunity
  • the eventual barbaric Christian oppression and savagery symbolized and represented by the inquisition and its "remedies" for heresy
  • the adoption of the "waiting for the Lord to come" mentality
  • a new idolatry based on Bibliolatry, worship of the disciples, Mariology, and faith in the Church

To the educated and enlightened believer in Yeshua, this all seems so dark, foreboding, primitive and retarded.

If you grant that the inauguration of the salvation of the human race depends upon coming into unity on everything that matters, the close disciples failed miserably in this regard. Instead of staying together and doing this, they evidently for the most part went their separate ways. Thomas was the one that understood the most, and yet he either did not understand this, or he tried and failed, and went off to Ceylon in disgust seeking some people in a different culture that were not so saturated with the false Hebrew paradigm. Maybe it took John a long time to realize this truth and that the Christianity that developed around him was never going to be fruitful. Thus he belatedly wrote his corrective Gospel as he was never going to come into unity with the community around him. Who knows what attempts he made before he also left the area?

The bottom line is that the perversity and failure of these so-called apostles have essentially condemned the human race to another 2,000* years of misery under the human condition. As such, these failures are monstrous and are nothing short of outrageous and deplorable! When these disciples realize the opportunity that they missed, they will be embarrassed until the whole sordid mess is forgotten in the future ongoing celebration of life and the Kingship. Except for John and Thomas, they will NEVER be regarded as greater than Mary the prostitute and her siblings, the FRIENDS of Yeshua!

* 1300 years in the CE chronology favored by this site.

Home   Site Sections   Article Map   Contact   Store   Contributions   Survey