Imminent FulfillmentImmortality,  Safety, Empowerment, Equality, KnowledgeUnity, Society

Should not intelligent, reasonable men of good will be able to agree on all things that matter?

"There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to
  one who is striking at the root."
- Henry David Thoreau
Site Sections, Subject List, Article Synopses and other features

Christendom Analyzed
Basic Questions
Christendom Issues
Christendom Analyzed
Christianity & Hellenism
God is Dead Movement
Greying of the Prophets
Human Spiritual Incredulity
John the Baptist Syndrome
Quasi-Christian Sects
Religion as a Product
Weeping for Lazarus
What Went Wrong?

Christendom Challenged
4 Laments on the Failure
Common Theological Assumptions
Doing the Lord's Work
God's Blessings
Jesus Should Have Said
Letter to a Christian
Major Theological Differences
Multitudinous Heresies
Preacher Impertinence
Sanctuary was Moloch's Tent
Simple Mistakes by Christendom
Spiritual Tachisme Religion

Christendom Condemned
Criticizing the 12 Disciples
Children of God
Christendom's Twin Pillars
Major Mistakes
Mysticism vs Understanding
Christendom Idolatry
Christian Liturgy
Rites and Sacraments
Subversion of Christianity
Unity Chasm
Confused Christian Terms
Why I'm not Christian

Introduction Material
Introduction Articles
Word Definitions
Human Condition

Christianity Material
Bible/Canon Issues
Christendom Analyzed

Jesus Material
Jesus' Teachings
Aspects of Jesus
5 Gospels Canon

Philosophy Material
Academic Education
Paradigm Material
Philosophers of Note
Philosophical Issues
Philosophy Metaphysics
Psychological Issues
Religious Miscellaneous
Sociological Material
Theological Basics
Theological Issues
Theological Misc

Theological Skeptical

Cosmology, Creation,
Geophysical Material

Cosmology Material
Creation Issues
Geophysical Material

Reconstruction &
Mythology Material
Chronology Revision
Golden Age Themes
History Revision
Misc Ancient Myth Material
Modern Mythology Material
Psycho-Catastrophe Articles
Saturn-Jupiter Material
Symbol Development
Venus-Mars Material
1994 Velikovsky Symposium

Miscellaneous Material
Book Critiques Links
Misc Biology Links
Misc Issues/Conclusions
Poetry & Fun Material
PDF Download Files
Lecture & Video Links
Site Features Links
Spiritual Products online store



Understanding the truth about God was precluded by the prevailing
entrenched paradigm in the early Christian community.
- Site author

What Went Wrong?
Updated: 01/18/2021

There is no question that Yeshua had a significant impact on his society at the time, an impact that came to be an ongoing major influence in the world, and that Christianity was born and proceeded with fervor. The disciples were inspired by their time with the great teacher and the early group of Christians grew. Of course, the whole nation of Israel had heard about Yeshua and the relevant events, and by some estimates 50% of the population had a favorable and sympathetic stance toward Yeshua. How could they not? He identified with them and their problems. He didn't talk down to them from temple tiers or from behind a physical, psychological barrier lectern up on an elevated stage, but talked up to them standing at the bottom of a slope or in the lowest possible position, from a boat on the water. He had healed a lot of them or their relatives and friends, and he had never threatened them or beleaguered them in any way.

The early "church" lived in a bubble of expectation and confidence that Yeshua would return very soon–we are talking days, weeks, maybe months but not initially years–and grew rapidly with an attitude of joyous loving, sharing, and celebration. At least until the persecution set in. Even then the numbers continued to increase. All of this is unique and impressive, but it didn't last. It was and is not enough for the following reasons.

At the time of Yeshua on earth, the Jews were looking for a savior of the nation, not of the cosmos nor even of the global world. They were looking for their own Messiah who was to be a representative of God and king on earth, and they had a short list of miracles that would qualify and verify such a person. But they had no concept that THE ORIGINATOR himself would come instead of some lesser Messiah. Anything but that!

Matthew 16:18-20   On THIS rock I will build my responsible group (Ecclesia), and the powers of death shall not prevail against it.  I will give you the keys of the kingship of the heavens, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."  Then he strictly charged the disciples to tell no one that he was the Christ.

The last sentence of the passage has always been interpreted as Yeshua wanting to keep his Messiahship a secret, or at least spare the disciples some trouble, but these understandings make no sense in the light of so many other factors that counter this thinking. Given that the title "Christ" is the Greek term for Messiah, what DOES make sense is that Yeshua did not want them to think this nor to promote the Messiah identification any more than was existing already. Yeshua was MUCH different and MUCH MORE than a Messiah, and for more than one reason did not want to be thought of as an earthly king!

Another way of looking at their mindset is to see that they expected the Messiah to DO great and significant things, to operate with power and authority, to set things right on earth according to their understanding, but not to PROCLAIM great things about God. They didn't need that! What they were NOT expecting was for the Messiah to bring them significant NEW truth, or corrective truth. They didn't need that! Certainly not the mind-blowing, paradigm-shattering, blasphemous truth that Yeshua proclaimed. No! Anything but that!

The disciples were for the most part low-class ignorant fishermen who were attracted to Yeshua and began to follow him. They soon became enamored with him, and why not? He was charismatic, yet secure, unafraid, mature, gracious, in control, and he made them feel loved. He was warm and gentle with them and never made them feel guilty. They were entranced by his amicable, non-judgmental spirit, AND he did miracles. What's not to like? But they were slow to even associate him with even being the Messiah, and even after calming the storm and saving their boat from being swamped, they said, "Who then is this, that even the wind and sea obey him?" And Yeshua himself was not comfortable with the Messiah identification. He came with a much bigger agenda than the Jewish concept of the Messiah would portray, an agenda to replace their paradigm of God. Were they open to that? No, NO! Anything but that!

When the disciples did confess that Yeshua was the Messiah, this was just an understanding that he was a temporary representative from God. The paradigm of Judaism defined God in terms of ultimate power and control, a transcendent-to-human being whose will must be honored, or else! God couldn't be just a gracious man of humility. He couldn't be a friend who fished naked at night with them, and urinated over the side of the boat. He couldn't be a person who had friends like Mary, Martha, and Lazarus. He couldn't be a person that would hang out with prostitutes and publicans. He couldn't be a man that didn't rail against the sins of the flesh, or even rail against the oppression of the Romans. And he couldn't be a person that would stay out of the limelight.

He couldn't be a mere human that would get his feet dirty with the dust contaminated with spittle, bird droppings, and donkey doo-doo. He couldn't be a person that had no relish for consolidating political power and made no moves to install himself as a religious or political leader. He couldn't be a person who healed sinners and then told them not to tell anyone. He couldn't be a person who was THAT far out of sync with their religion, its customs, forms and leadership. He couldn't be a person who would rather serve than be served, rather wash their feet than have them wash his. Doctrinal thinking is all but if not unanimous that he did this just to set an example, and it is rarely if ever considered that this is just the way he ALWAYS IS.

And finally, he just couldn't be a person who would allow himself to be arrested, mocked and humiliated, tortured, and then hanged on a cross until dead amidst traitors, insurrectionists, and rabble rousing rebels. "...nothing could be further removed from Judaism than the concept of God Himself suffering death."[*]  NO! NO! NO! ANYTHING BUT THAT!!!

Oh, their hearts were moved mightily. But NOT their minds; not their PARADIGM of God. That was the ultimate sacred thing, you see, their paradigm, and not even God himself could induce a major change in their thinking and belief ON THIS LEVEL.

And so it stands today after several hundred years. Christendom is still focused on the TRADITIONAL posited transcendence of the Creator, the God of power and control, and our own inferiority and our own less-than-sterling behavior, still focused on and venerating into idolatry ancient writings with seriously flawed concepts instead of the words of Yeshua and his claim to be the paradigm, the truth, the light for understanding and the way to life without death. At this time still, the greatest most amazing thing in our world is the perverse propensity for the human mind to cling to irrational, illogical, unreasonable, unworthy beliefs; beliefs demeaning to both God and ourselves.

The faulty foundation of Paul and disciples

Outside of what John and Thomas wrote indicating that these two understood much, there is no evidence that any of the balance of the disciples ever chose to believe the best about God, ever overcame their primal sin. Outside of what John and Thomas wrote implying they believed, there is no evidence that any of the other disciples ever chose to believe the best about THEMSELVES, about how the Creator is, was, and always will be totally and only–psychologically and spiritually–human, a loving, sharing being of our own NATURE who has extended equality to us as his children; and how the cosmic system will never be completely healed and perfectly functional unless and until the humans on earth choose to believe the best and take their place as equal citizens of the universe. It is simply a mistake to think that, just because they were followers of Yeshua, they understood him or his message.

What it comes down to is that Christianity is built within the Judaic paradigm AND on the faulty foundation based in the ideas of the disciple Peter and "apostle" Paul, and not on the overall message in the life and words of the J-person. He has now become only a figurehead, and emblem while his teaching is buried under the Old Testament and the balance of the New.

...many people who have a vague childish affection for a half-remembered Yeshua, have never used their adult critical faculties on the matter at all. They hardly seem to see the paramount importance of His claim to be God. - Phillips, J. B., Your God is too Small, MacMillan Publishing Co., New York, NY 10022, p. 82.

[*] That God suffers in sympathy with the sufferings of mankind, however, is a well established Jewish doctrine (e.g. Bava Batra, 73b).  This Jewish view, however, was denounced as blasphemous by Christian theologians (e.g. at the Disputation of Paris, 1240) as akin to the Patripassian heresy, the orthodox Christian view being that God the Father was 'impassible', and even the Son of God could suffer only in the flesh. - Maccoby, Hyam, "Chapter Nine", The Sacred Executioner, Thames & Hudson, 1982.

Home   Site Sections   Article Map   Contact   Store   Contributions   Survey