IF I SEEK US
Imminent FulfillmentImmortality,  Safety, Empowerment, Equality, KnowledgeUnity, Society

Should not intelligent, reasonable men of good will be able to agree on all things that matter?

"There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to
  one who is striking at the root."
- Henry David Thoreau
Site Sections, Subject List, Article Synopses and other features

The Human Condition

A Look Ahead for USA
Catastrophe Influence
Defending the Faith
Essence of Koran
Evil of Ordinary
Fall of Man
Garden, Fall, Restore
Human Consensus
Human Context
Human Nature
Humanity Questions
Industrial Revolution
Orthodoxy
A Pertinent Discussion
Personal Accnt/Question
Religious Diversity
Saturn in Human History
Solutions to Disunity
State of Academia
State of Philosophy
The Third Story
The Twilight Zone
 

Introduction Material
Introduction Articles
Word Definitions
Human Condition

Christianity Material
Bible/Canon Issues
Christendom Analyzed

Jesus Material
Jesus' Teachings
Aspects of Jesus
5 Gospels Canon

Philosophy Material
Academic Education
Paradigm Material
Philosophers of Note
Philosophical Issues
Philosophy Metaphysics
Psychological Issues
Religious Miscellaneous
Sociological Material
Theological Basics
Theological Issues
Theological Misc

Theological Skeptical

Cosmology, Creation,
Geophysical Material

Cosmology Material
Creation Issues
Geophysical Material

Reconstruction &
Mythology Material
Archeology-Material
Chronology Revision
Golden Age Themes
History Revision
Language-Development
Misc Ancient Myth Material
Modern Mythology Material
Psycho-Catastrophe Articles
Saturn-Jupiter Material
Symbol Development
Venus-Mars Material
1994 Velikovsky Symposium

Miscellaneous Material
Book Critiques Links
Misc Biology Links
Misc Issues/Conclusions
Poetry & Fun Material
PDF Download Files
Lecture & Video Links
Site Features Links
Site article checklist
Spiritual Products online store

 

 

Milgram Study
04/11/2021

Casti, John L., Paradigms Lost, Chapter 3:It's in the Genes, AVON BOOKS, The Hearst Corporation, 105 Madison Avenue, New York NY 100016, P.143

A few years ago, in one of the most fascinating and disturbing experiments in the annals of behavioral psychology, Stanley Milgram of Yale tested forty subjects from all walks of life for their willingness to obey instructions given by a "leader" in a situation in which the subjects might feel a personal abhorrence for the actions they were called upon to perform.  Specifically, Milgram told each volunteer "teacher-subject" that the experiment was in the noble cause of education, and was designed to test whether or not punishing pupils for their mistakes would have a positive effect on the pupils.

Milgram's experimental setup involved placing the teacher before a panel of thirty switches with labels ranging from "15 Volts (Slight Shock)" to "450 Volts (Danger--Severe Shock)" in steps of 15 volts each.  The subject was told that whenever the pupil gave the wrong answer to a question, a shock was to be administered, beginning at the lowest level and increasing in severity with each successive wrong answer.  The supposed "pupil" was in reality an actor hired by Milgram to simulate receiving the shocks by emitting a spectrum of groans, screams, and writhings, together with an assortment of statements and expletives denouncing both the experiment and the experimenter.  Milgram told the subject to ignore the reactions of the pupil, and to administer whatever level of shock was called for as per the rule governing the experimental situation of the moment.

As the experiment unfolded, the pupil would deliberately give the wrong answers to questions posed by the teacher, thereby bringing on various electrical "punishments," even up to the danger level of 300 volts and beyond.  Many of the subjects balked at administering the higher levels of punishment, and turned to Milgram with questioning looks and/or complaints about continuing with the experiment.  In these situations, Milgram calmly explained that the teacher was to ignore the pupil's cries for mercy and carry on with the experiment.  If the subject was still reluctant to proceed, Milgram said that it was important for the sake of the experiment that the procedure be followed through to the end.  His final argument was "You have no other choice.  You must go on." What Milgram was out to discover was the number of subjects who would be willing to administer the highest levels of shock, even in the face of strong personal and moral revulsion against the rules and conditions of the experiment.

Prior to carrying out the experiment, Milgram explained his idea to a group of thirty-nine psychiatrists and asked them to predict the average percentage of people in an ordinary population who would be willing to administer the highest shock level of 450 volts.  The overwhelming consensus was that virtually all the subjects would refuse to obey the experimenter.  The psychiatrists felt that "most subjects would not go beyond 150 volts," and they expected that only 4 percent would go up to 300 volts.  Furthermore, they thought that only a pathological, sadistic, lunatic fringe of about 1 in 1,000 would give the highest shock of 450 volts.

What were the actual results? Well, over 60 percent of the subjects continued to obey Milgram up to the 450-volt limit!  In repetitions of the experiment in other countries—South Africa, Italy, West Germany, Australia—the percentage of obedient teachers was even higher, reaching 85 percent in Munich.  How can we possibly account for this vast discrepancy between what calm, rational, knowledgeable men predict in the comfort of their study, and what pressured, flustered, but cooperative "teachers" actually do in the laboratory of real life?

NATURE/NURTURE: SENSE OR NONSENSE?

An excellent description of Milgram's experimental setup and results is found in the book: Koestler, A. Janus.  New York: Random House, 1978.

Koestler notes the important variation of the experiment in which Milgram allowed the subjects to inflict any level of shock they wished as a punishment for a wrong answer, rather than being compelled to use a level determined by the leader.  In this case, 38 out of the 40 subjects refused to go beyond a level of 150 volts, the level at which the pupil made his first loud cry, with the average shock administered a measly 54 volts.  Milgram's own account of these experiments can be found in his 1974 book Obedience to Authority.

 

Home   Site Sections   Article Map   Contact   Store   Contributions   Survey